logo AIRI
News archive
A constructive dialogue on the Innovation Agreements between the MISE and AIRI Priority Technologies

A constructive dialogue on the Innovation Agreements between the MISE and AIRI

A was held on Friday, April 8, 2022 webinar organized by AIRI for its members with the General Directorate for business incentives of the Ministry of Economic Development with the aim of illustrating the characteristics, presentation methods and main elements of the "New Agreements for Innovation".

Speakers included Dr. Giuseppe BRONZINO, General Manager, General Directorate for business incentives and Dr. Giorgio GIOVAGNOLI, Manager of Division VII - Interventions for research, innovation and large investment projects, together with Dr. Girolamo DEFELICE, Division VII.

The refinancing of 1 billion euros, through the PNC (Complementary National Plan) linked to the National Recovery and Resilience Plan (PNRR) of the Innovation Agreements for large projects on enabling technologies and the 750 million euros allocated to projects in the framework of the "Italian Green New Deal" confirm that Research, Development and Innovation (RS&I) are primary objectives of Italian industrial policy in line with the vision and objectives of Europe.

For AIRI, these are important tools to incentivize the large Research and Development projects of companies which in the five-year period 2015-2020 activated around 5 billion euros of investments with 113 projects presented under the MISE Innovation Agreements alone, of which 58 were subsidized for approximately 306 million euros, according to the recent MISE report "Interventions to support economic and productive activities: characteristics and evolutions" of the 2021.

During the meeting AIRI considered positive:

- the regulatory change introduced to speed up the co-financing procedure of projects by local public administrations (regions and autonomous provinces), which, if interested, will have to promptly submit an expression of interest to the MISE aimed at signing a Framework Agreement with the same Ministry by May 3rd;
- the speeding up of the procedural process for project approval also made possible by the adoption of a single-stage procedure which provides for the presentation, at the time of submission of the application, of the final executive project which, if it complies with the eligibility requirements, is sent to the preliminary investigation phase which must be completed within a maximum of 90 days from the date of application.

However, AIRI has some reservations:

- on the abolition of the upper limit of €40 million as the maximum cost of the project which could lead to the monopolization of resources by large-scale projects of large national players, limiting the possibility of access to medium and medium-large companies;
- on the adoption of an eligibility ranking determined on the basis of the chronological order of submission of applications which could lead to critical issues (de facto a click-day) in the event that the funds ran out a few minutes after the opening time of the desk.

In this regard, the Rapporteurs shared the doubts expressed and envisaged the possibility that, following the closure of the desk, if any critical issues in the presentation were confirmed, additional resources could be used that could allow the ranking to move forward.

With regard to the possible limited scope of participation of SMEs, the MISE also points out that a notice has already been opened for projects on the circular economy with a smaller dimensional cut, that notices will be issued for tenders relating to Artificial Intelligence and Blockchain with a cut of 500 thousand euros and a tender relating to the Green and Innovation Deal with eligible costs with a lower minimum threshold (presumed to be equal to 3 million euros). In addition to this, the Ministry is evaluating the possibility of activating a one-stop procedure aimed at SMEs for projects with lower cost size ranges.

According to the MISE report, SMEs are the main beneficiaries of the benefits granted (more than one billion euros) in 2020 alone. Overall, the national and regional benefits granted for Research, Development and Innovation amount to 1.8 billion. This is more than 20% of the total benefits granted at national and regional government level (8.2 billion). RS&I therefore remains one of the main industrial policy objectives at both national and regional level.
Specifically, the Innovation Agreements are part of the Sustainable Growth Fund, an instrument strongly supported by the Italian Association for Industrial Research (AIRI) and introduced following the 2012 reorganization of incentives, inheriting the revolving peculiarity and operational flexibility of the Technological Innovation Fund (FIT) from whose transformation it derives.

Between 2015 and 2020, there were 1038 applications for business financing from the Sustainable Growth Fund of the MISE for over 2.8 billion euros in concessions granted. This is an amount equal to 58% of all interventions (around 5 billion) for Research, Development and Innovation (RS&I) granted by central administrations and 14.28% of all national-level incentives for industrial policy objectives (around 20 billion).

The data can be considered in line with the order of magnitude of the total financial resources (8 billion) that in 2015 AIRI estimated were necessary to achieve the development of the technologies identified in the AIRI Volume in 3-5 years "The Innovations of the Next Future. Priority Technologies for Industry”.

AIRI therefore associates itself with the positive assessments expressed in the aforementioned MISE report regarding the Innovation Agreements "with respect to the design of the measure and the data obtained from the analysis of its operation and some case studies, despite the fact that some operational difficulties have emerged over time, linked to the complexity of the negotiation phase and which have reverberated on the completion times of the process. The positive opinion concerns the coherence of the design of the measure with respect to its objectives and with respect to the national framework of policies to support R&D&I activities, with particular regarding the aspects of additionality, adequacy and proportionality of the regime".

Read also: Airi Webinar: Agreements for Innovation and incentive strategy - with the General Directorate for MISE business incentives