logo AIRI
News archive
Priority Technologies

Industry 4.0 outlines a new industrial policy scenario for RS&I

During 2016, particularly in the second half of the year, the development of an industrial policy line based on technological innovation and consequently on broader support for industrial research was outlined.

An attention that had almost disappeared from the government agenda (see for example the abolition tout court of Framework Law 297/99 for the support of industrial research) with the exception of the launch in 2012 of the Sustainable Research Program launched by the Monti Government and in particular conceived and supported by the pro-tempore Minister Passera.
An industrial policy line that is being identified in development of fiscal leverage to support industrial research and promotion of “Industry 4.0”, which is based on a wider diffusion of digital innovation.

There has therefore been a real quantum leap in the Government's attention, and in particular in the role of the MISE, towards the urgent need for support for significant development and technological adaptation of the national industry.
Airi immediately grasped the importance of this scenario and therefore placed and is placing considerable attention, particularly on what concerns the aspect of tax leverage, so as to contribute to the development of the operation and simplification of the Patent Box and the improvement of the Tax Credit. At the same time, it is continuing to support the need for appropriate tenders within the Sustainable Growth Fund aimed at maintaining public support in sectors and on industrial issues of real interest for the country, characterized by broad consistency with the EU Programme. Horizon 2020.
In this context, Airi has also paid and is paying significant attention to the support of industrial research structures, also including, with a unique associative commitment in Italy, the research structures of foreign companies operating in Italy, thus highlighting the key role that many multinationals or other foreign companies operating in Italy play for the growth of Italian industrial research.
Thus, within the scope of the 2017 Stability Law, the extension of the benefit of the tax credit was obtained for research carried out in Italian research structures of foreign companies and in particular of branches of multinationals based in Italy, which until now were excluded without reason from the legislation.
This is an important result for supporting the growth of technologically advanced research activities in Italy and at the same time for activating a significant number of qualified positions available for our young researchers in the field of industrial research, who today are increasingly forced to look for suitable work outside the country.

It should also be noted that the 2017 Stability Law has implemented other important requests brought forward by Airi since 2015 regarding the tax credit. This involves the extension of the legislation to all company researchers and technicians, previously limited to qualified researchers only, as well as the adjustment of the tax benefit from 25% to 50% for all research and development expenses identified in the legislation approved in the 2015 Stability Law, but also including expenses for industrial research projects with strong prospects of technological impact. A tax credit structure defined as "Byzantine" as early as 2015 has thus been overcome.
Unfortunately it seemed that the regulation could be extended to all companies' annual research and development expenses, as is the case for example in France, and not just the incremental part. Unfortunately, as has often already happened, this opportunity was cut at the last moment, probably in favor of other items considered by the pro-tempore Government to be of greater priority.

Airi will continue to request the extension of the tax credit from an incremental form to a volumetric form, also in order to adapt the legislation to an impact on national industrial research similar to that currently underway in countries that are our competitors such as France and Spain.
He is of the opinion that the measures of the 2017 Stability Law, which focus on the improvement of automatic fiscal levers and in particular of the Tax Credit, in themselves innovative and welcome, being however inspired by a vision of technological neutrality cannot alone compete with the strong impact of large plans which aim to develop, as happens in Germany, strategic lines of technological growth taking advantage of a wide use of targeted measures. It is also true that this approach has not brought the expected results to Italy in the past, with the exception, however, of a significant role of the Sustainable Growth Fund, for which in the period 2012-2016 there was support, even if limited, of technological issues relevant for the country through the disbursement of several tranches following one-stop tenders or direct negotiation, in particular for large companies.
Airi therefore hopes for the continuation of funding for this program, also by exploiting, if possible in a useful way, the PON funds.

The in-depth study of the potential of "Industry 4.0" for the digital adaptation of the Italian manufacturing system pushed the Association to produce a preliminary document, which was taken into account in the fact-finding investigation that the X Commission of the Chamber of Deputies (production activities, trade and tourism) carried out in July 2016.
To contribute to the success of "Industry 4.0" for national technological competitiveness, broadening its role compared only to the growth of the digital skills of the national industry, we published a organic report in order to make a further contribution to improving the objectives and methods of implementation of "Industry 4.0" compared to what is currently presented by Minister Calenda.
This is a valuable work of in-depth analysis of the innovative potential of "Industry 4.0" with an evaluation of its impact in its current form on the technological competitiveness of a large part of the Members. The objective in 2017 will be to provide a further concrete contribution to the implementation of "Industry 4.0" which considers for the national manufacturing industry how to combine the need for technological recovery in the digital sector with the support of the development of new processes / products or new "hard" technologies, also relying on what is reported in the IX Edition of "Priority Technologies - Innovations of the near future" published in 2016.

Regarding the many critical points of national policy for both industrial and public research, Airi notes that significant problems still remain in the implementation of the National Research Plan (PNR) under the responsibility of the MIUR, which today appears to be a somewhat "exhausted" Ministry, or rather politically little considered.
For example, the recently approved PNR is still substantially unimplemented with regard to the provision of what has long been defined to support important and "intelligent" initiatives (such as national technological clusters) using national funds. Furthermore, it will be necessary to check in 2017 whether the basic hypothesis of the PNR according to which the Italian research system, including industrial research, should draw from the EU plan is being implemented. Horizon 2020 resources equal to approximately 10% of the total available (very difficult objective without a strong lobby in Brussels from the MIUR).
Therefore, a check on the implementation status of the PNR, possibly followed by its revision, is absolutely inevitable so that a valuable document with related proposals does not turn out, as has almost always happened in the past for the PNR, a document that is not implemented in its entirety or even useless.
The aforementioned difficulty of operational activation causes delays in disbursements for a large part of the National Technological Clusters and suggests, if these disbursements are not activated in time, the danger that they could become a sensational flop equal to that suffered by the 2015 Industry Project.

In this regard, Airi had activated preliminary contact with Minister Giannini, which was obviously blocked by the fall of the Government and in particular by the failure to reconfirm the Minister in the current Government.
2017 now opens with the aim for Airi to develop adequate initiatives and pressure to improve the industrial policy lines outlined above, with the hope that the MIUR will become aware of having to recover the time, skills and political weight lost starting from 2008-2009.
In particular, Airi intends to address two fundamental issues:

The need to implement at the level of the Presidency of the Council and the competent Ministries, a industrial research development support model based on a three-level process that is: a negotiating tool for large-scale projects that can be used in particular by large industry, a one-stop tool aimed at the growth of industrial research also by SMEs in sectors of primary interest for national industry, which operates with simplified and flexible participation, evaluation and disbursement procedures, and finally a strong and broad tax credit that is volumetric and not incremental.
The need for take into account a hard core of "hard" technologies typical of the manufacturing industry in the “Industry 4.0” paradigm. To this end, Airi has already brought together technology analysts from leading member companies, and not only, who are outlining those "hard" technologies that can make a rapid transition towards a greater digital content of the classic models of mechatronics and robotic automation typical of the manufacturing industry non-"traumatic", as well as analyzing the impact of this transition on the organizational and management structure of industrial research.

Renato Ugo
President Airi